| · The Herd's Rules · Portal |
Help
Search
Members
Calendar
|
| Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register ) | Resend Validation Email |
| Pages: (2) [1] 2 ( Go to first unread post ) | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
| Sherlocko |
Posted: Oct 25 2009, 12:27 PM
|
||
![]() Angry Purple Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 2,646 Member No.: 1,098 Joined: 12-March 06 |
So, say that I have a khorne wargor in a herd 9" away from..oh, I donīt know, a greater demon. If I choose not to charge with the herd, donīt roll a 1 on unruly but finds out that the character is within charge range I have to charge with him. So far so good.
But here comes the tricky part. When a character wich is ITP joins a non-ITP unit he loses ITP until he leaves the unit. Considering the S&S-FAQ I would assume that the character donīt leave the unit until you actually move him. So am I right assuming that my khorne wargor would have to take a terror test if he charges by himself? If so, if he fails, does he run by himself or does the whole unit run? Or I am just missing something... --------------------
BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERHAMMER |
||
| Kawazu |
Posted: Oct 25 2009, 01:41 PM
|
||||
![]() Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 812 Member No.: 3,459 Joined: 29-December 08 |
That's a good point!
I think it's like you say, the frenzied boy loses ITP, since it doesn't seem to me there's written in any point of the frenzy description that a frenzied unit/character cannot ever lose the ITP. --------------------
ROFL My CMON gallery MY BLOG Warhammer record: Warriors of Chaos W 4 D 2 L 0 Waiting for a new beast book to play with... |
||||
| daftgor |
Posted: Oct 25 2009, 02:02 PM
|
![]() Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 2,180 Member No.: 2,022 Joined: 26-October 07 |
hehe, thats a funny rules artifact
-------------------- Daftgor (the friendly neighbourhood troll)
Ŋ\(°_o)/Ŋ -Braaaaains! |
| Sherlocko |
Posted: Oct 25 2009, 05:13 PM
|
||
![]() Angry Purple Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 2,646 Member No.: 1,098 Joined: 12-March 06 |
And since he donīt leave the unit until after the terror test, would that make the whole unit flee? It seems pretty weird, but what do you other rule-dudes say?
--------------------
BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERHAMMER |
||
| Kawazu |
Posted: Oct 25 2009, 08:51 PM
|
||||||
![]() Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 812 Member No.: 3,459 Joined: 29-December 08 |
I think so. I can't recall the page now and I'm too lazy to turn my chair and grab the book ( --------------------
ROFL My CMON gallery MY BLOG Warhammer record: Warriors of Chaos W 4 D 2 L 0 Waiting for a new beast book to play with... |
||||||
| daftgor |
Posted: Oct 25 2009, 10:06 PM
|
![]() Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 2,180 Member No.: 2,022 Joined: 26-October 07 |
I can just imagine it
Wargor: "grrr.... treeman must die!" Foe-render: "Don't do it, man! He'll kill us all, run for our lives!" -------------------- Daftgor (the friendly neighbourhood troll)
Ŋ\(°_o)/Ŋ -Braaaaains! |
| decker_cky |
Posted: Oct 25 2009, 11:54 PM
|
![]() Ministry of Truth Group: Admins Posts: 10,794 Member No.: 7 Joined: 23-November 03 |
I'm not so sure...looking at the character and psychology rules, nothing is covered there, nor is it specifically addressed in the normal terror rules. Just refers to the unit failing the terror test having to flee. In this case, the unit taking then failing the test is the character, not the herd. Therefore, the frenzied khorne character has to flee from within the herd upon failing the terror test.
If it were fear...the character would be stuck in place and wouldn't leave the unit, and the unit would be bound to the speed of it's slowest model (aka...the character). -------------------- http://dethfairy.mybrute.com/
If it bleeds, we can kill it. ![]() And don't forget Untergor. Remember that above all else, we'll always have Untergor Decker's Eclectic Painting and Modeling Diary - Last updated October 27/09 - Assorted Skaven Decker's Beast Blog - Last updated November 10/09 - Converted Shaggoth. Tallarn 47th Light Infantry Army Diary - Last updated March 29/09 - Leman Russ Eradicator |
| the Thing in the Woods |
Posted: Nov 1 2009, 08:59 PM
|
|
Foe Render Group: Members Posts: 60 Member No.: 2,012 Joined: 20-October 07 |
Yeah, but the ld test is thrown before movement of any kind is done. So the herd ans wargor would flee if they fail
Quite hug and kissed up -------------------- Something nasty and fanged...
|
| Meals |
Posted: Nov 1 2009, 09:38 PM
|
||||
![]() Doom Bull Group: Members Posts: 587 Member No.: 2,522 Joined: 17-March 08 |
The only thing I can come up with that could relate to this is the FAQ ruling on Stand & Shoot at characters charging out of units.
You stand and shoot while the character is in the unit, (assuming they have the range to the unit), and Stand & Shoot occurs after you take the test, since you test as soon as you find whether you are in range to charge or not. I'm not 100% sure on when the Psych test is taken but that's my understanding. Its not like any of the charging rules are properly clarified in terms of order...hopefully in 8th Ed. --------------------
Forum Arguments are like Nascar: Everything goes round and round in pointless circles until you get lucky and there's a fiery explosion. |
||||
| Beastlord Karankawa |
Posted: Nov 2 2009, 02:38 AM
|
||
![]() Mr. Primitive screw-head Group: Moderators Posts: 6,673 Member No.: 66 Joined: 20-March 04 |
Agree there - the character and the unit ARE the unit until the character charges out. So the unit would take a terror test, and upon passing, the character leaves the unit. Upon failing, the whole unit falls back.
--------------------
|
||
| decker_cky |
Posted: Nov 2 2009, 07:04 AM
|
![]() Ministry of Truth Group: Admins Posts: 10,794 Member No.: 7 Joined: 23-November 03 |
My interpretation is that the character is a unit regardless (protected from being targeted by being in a rank and file unit), and the unit with the character is another unit.
In the case of the stand and shoot ruling, it's because the shooting can't be at the character until he leaves the unit. -------------------- http://dethfairy.mybrute.com/
If it bleeds, we can kill it. ![]() And don't forget Untergor. Remember that above all else, we'll always have Untergor Decker's Eclectic Painting and Modeling Diary - Last updated October 27/09 - Assorted Skaven Decker's Beast Blog - Last updated November 10/09 - Converted Shaggoth. Tallarn 47th Light Infantry Army Diary - Last updated March 29/09 - Leman Russ Eradicator |
| Karlore |
Posted: Nov 2 2009, 08:41 AM
|
|
Ungor Group: Members Posts: 19 Member No.: 3,734 Joined: 28-October 09 |
I am surely not an authority on it but I would imagine that the Unit would not test and flee. there is no clear cut on the rules so most of the time we are left to use our imaginations. If a character wants to charge out at some scary dude I doubt his boys are gonna stop him since they have nothing to do with it really. just sit back and drink in how insane their leader is. I mean these are the BEASTS they would be hungry to see their leader succeed or fail against such a foe.
Then again it could be interpreted any other way you know what this means! roll a D6 |
| Sherlocko |
Posted: Nov 2 2009, 09:39 AM
|
||||
![]() Angry Purple Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 2,646 Member No.: 1,098 Joined: 12-March 06 |
This is where I agree. Since you take the test to be able to declare the charge, you are still with the unit when taking the test. --------------------
BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERHAMMER |
||||
| Tauren |
Posted: Nov 2 2009, 02:19 PM
|
![]() Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 2,394 Member No.: 1,885 Joined: 5-August 07 |
I think the difference is who is actually charging it. Remember he does not lose ITP from frenzy, he retains it even when in a unit that doesn't. He simply does not follow the rules of it. It is just that he simply must follow the unit he is attached too, thusly for the purposes of fleeing the unit fleeing will cause the hero to flee. That said when he charges, it is him alone that is charging, not the unit. You test for who is charging. So in my opinion if it is just him charging then he will not have to test.
That's my interpretation. -------------------- ![]() "I could have charged cold-one knights in the rear with minotaurs... I wussed out..." /facepalm ~Tauren at a warbands tournament. |
| Sherlocko |
Posted: Nov 2 2009, 04:36 PM
|
||||
![]() Angry Purple Shaggoth Group: Members Posts: 2,646 Member No.: 1,098 Joined: 12-March 06 |
Where is this rule? --------------------
BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERHAMMER |
||||
Pages: (2) [1] 2 |
![]() ![]() ![]() |